The Boys: 10 Times Butcher Was WAY More Evil Than Homelander
Butcher by name, butcher by nature...
screenrant.comHere’s a concise update on why Billy Butcher hates Homelander, with a focus on recent developments in The Boys.
-
Why the hatred started: Butcher’s vendetta against Homelander is rooted in personal tragedy and a deep distrust of the Supes’ power. In the show, Homelander is widely seen as responsible for causing pain and harm to people close to Butcher, particularly the disappearance/trauma surrounding his wife Becca, which fuels Butcher’s obsession to take Homelander down. This dynamic creates a personal, laser-focused animosity rather than a generic superhero feud.[1]
-
Evolution of their relationship: Over time their relationship shifts from one-sided hero-hating to a more complex, almost symbiotic tension. Butcher’s relentless pursuit of justice (or vengeance) against Homelander exposes Homelander’s own vulnerabilities and loneliness, leading to a twisted, mutual fixation rather than a simple villain-vs-hero conflict.[3][5]
-
Why this matters in Season 4/5: The rivalry is portrayed as one of the central engines of the series, driving Butcher to extreme methods and forcing Homelander to reckon with the consequences of his actions and his role as a father. The dynamic is often described as “two sides of the same coin,” highlighting how their paths mirror and clash with each other’s darkest impulses.[8][9]
-
Notable moments and themes: Critics and fans highlight moments where Butcher’s methods threaten to eclipse Homelander’s brutality, and vice versa, underscoring how their enmity pushes the moral boundaries of the show. Some discussions explore whether Butcher could become a worse villain than Homelander, a debate that underscores the shifting line between heroism and villainy in The Boys.[7][9]
Illustration (example scene you might recall): A confrontation where both men push each other to reveal the limits of their humanity—Butcher with his no-holds-barred tactics, and Homelander with his fear of losing control and the burdens of parenthood and optics.
If you’d like, I can pull more specific reactions from recent episodes or summarize how this feud has progressed across seasons 4 and 5 with direct quotes or scene references. I can also set up a quick timeline of key confrontations between Butcher and Homelander.