Has Anthony Stolarz been good enough for the Leafs?

Has Anthony Stolarz Been Good Enough for the Leafs?

The Toronto Maple Leafs have experienced an inconsistent start to this season following a division-winning year last season. One of their biggest strengths last year was their goaltending.

Before the season began, Leafs general manager Brad Treliving signed Anthony Stolarz to a four-year contract with an average annual value (AAV) of $3.75 million. This came after Stolarz posted a .926 save percentage in 34 games, making the deal appear promising.

Current Performance Analysis

Despite the fresh contract, there have been discussions regarding Stolarz's play this season. It is important to highlight that the Leafs' defense has been insufficient, contributing to his challenges.

"If you want to put your goalie in a position to succeed, they simply can't see that many 'grade A' chances."

Statistically, it feels like more high-quality chances are getting past Stolarz compared to last year, which is supported by his numbers:

Overall, the Leafs' defensive struggles have heavily impacted Stolarz's ability to replicate last season's success.

Author's Summary

Anthony Stolarz's performance this season reflects not only his own play but also the Leafs' defensive weaknesses, limiting his potential to succeed as last year.

more

Editor In Leaf Editor In Leaf — 2025-11-08