The Yankees have a hole in left field after Cody Bellinger opted out of his contract, becoming a free agent. They could re-sign Bellinger, who hit 29 home runs and played excellent defense, but signing Kyle Tucker could bring star talent and roster depth.
The Yankees got value from Bellinger's $25 million contract, but his return wouldn't significantly impact their window. In contrast, signing Tucker could make their best team in the Aaron Judge era, albeit at a higher cost.
It would cost more than Cody Bellinger and could take the Yankees out of future sweepstakes, but 2025 was a year that resulted in massive internal developments that Hal Steinbrenner needs to buy into.
Author's summary: Yankees should pursue Kyle Tucker for roster depth.